Pros - Cons of a Vacuum Excavator



Vacuum excavation is the process of digging using suction created by a vacuum and is an alternative to mechanical excavation and manual labor.

Vacuum excavators appear quite dissimilar to traditional excavators. Vacuum excavator components consist of fresh water and debris tanks, suction tubes, hoses, pumps, and compressors. Depending on the needs of the contractor, they can be mounted on commercial-sized trucks or configured on trailers.

Think of a super-sized Shop-Vac® paired with a pressure washer when thinking of a vacuum excavator, often just called a ‘vac’. These machines utilize a high-pressure flow of water (hydro-vac), or stream of air, to break up the soil and excavate. The vac then sucks up the remaining dirt and debris from the hole, which is stored in the debris tank and hauled away from the jobsite.

“With hydro excavation, you are displacing the soil using water which creates a slurry and then you’re sucking up that slurry,” says Christopher Thompson, Ditch Witch Vacuum Excavation Product Manager. “So, you’re turning soil into a slurry, and then using the vac to remove that slurry.”

Why use a vacuum truck?

One of the greatest benefits of using a vac truck is its ability to remove soil, small stones, debris, and fluids without damaging nearby or underground infrastructure.

The teeth on the bucket of a traditional excavator can easily damage underground infrastructure, such as pipes and cables, whereas the airflow and/or water applied by the vac is considered a soft excavation method and is preferred to lessen the likelihood of damage. Any damages to underground infrastructure can cause some serious issues and affect many people. Hitting a water or telecommunications line is bad enough, but the stakes are even higher when excavators are operating around gas lines.

“Vac trucks are very useful when repairs need to be made on underground infrastructure and for exposing where these lines are, so you don’t hit them when installing new underground infrastructure or excavating for some other purpose,” says Thompson.

When installing underground utilities anywhere near existing infrastructure, best practices call for a vacuum excavator. For perpendicular installs, contractors can physically see the new install safely pass under or over what’s already in the ground by potholing, also called daylighting, to expose existing utilities." 

“And, when running a new underground infrastructure parallel to an existing underground infrastructure, you want to dig a hole with a vac truck every 10 feet to make sure the existing infrastructure is where the site map says it is,” says Thompson. “Things don’t always go into the ground perfectly straight, so you want to make sure the existing infrastructure didn’t bleed to the left or the right. So, by potholing in a series of 10 feet, you can guarantee what you are installing remains the proper distance from what is already there.”

In some situations, vacuum excavators can even be used in place of a trencher. When trenching in an area where it is known there is existing underground infrastructure, but are whereabouts is unknown and can’t easily be detected, a vac can be utilized. Known as slot trenching, a vac can be used to dig a narrow trench without the risk of damaging whatever is already in the ground.


Vac truck drawbacks

When digging in open areas with no existing underground infrastructure, a traditional excavator will get the job done fastest. While vacuum excavators use non-destructive means of displacing soil, this takes longer compared to traditional excavators. It is not practical for vac trucks to perform mass excavation for a new suburb, for example.

Another consideration when deciding to use a vac truck is the possibility that the dirt and water (the spoils) collected by the truck may not be able to be left on site. Depending on the regulations of local governments, once you introduce water into the soil, it might have to be brought to an offsite collection facility.


Additional vacuum excavation options

Trailers are also equipped with vacuum excavation equipment. You need a truck to tow it, but once the trailer is on location, the truck can be used for other purposes.

An important consideration is that there’s only one manufacturer of vacuum attachments for excavators. The TC2 manufactured by TinBin, as seen at The Utility Expo 2021, is a hydro vacuum attachment for mid-to-large-sized excavators. It works on a similar principle as vac trucks but comes in a much smaller package. Popular applications for the vacuum attachment include potholing and removing ballast from around rail lines.

The advantage of having an attachment to having a vac truck is only needing one machine on-site, which saves on capital costs and labor costs. Now, an excavator operator can pothole a utility with the vacuum attachment and then switch to the bucket for digging.

Subscribe to The Utility Expo monthly newsletter to receive more industry insights like this.  


Read Next

8 Questions to Ask When Buying a Vacuum Excavation Truck

10 Best U.S. States for Pipelaying Jobs in 2024

10 Best U.S. Cities for Pipelaying Jobs in 2024

Video: Vermeer Unveils Vxt300 Vac Truck with Improved Weight Distribution